A good toaster is every kitchen’s primary requirement for those busy mornings when you want a quick slice of toast with jam or butter. Today, we have compiled some of the best KitchenAid Toaster reviews to help you find that perfect accompaniment for your simple and quick breakfasts.

The best thing about KitchenAid is that it’s an American home appliance made in the USA, by a company that has over 100 years of legacy. Having a KitchenAid toaster on the kitchen countertop is not only essential for all singletons but also for families that prefer an easy toast or sandwich any time.

The common aspect of all KitchenAid toasters is that they are all pop-up models with a spring-loaded tray attached to keep the bread. When you lower the bread, the machine heats/ toasts both the sides, and when it’s fully toasted, the tray pops up to let you take the toast.

While buying a Kitchenaid toaster may sound simple, it’s easier said than done so we have reviewed all the models to carefully select the best ones for you. We have thoroughly reviewed each product and compared it with others in the category to determine what they excel at and what they lack.

Read on to find our unbiased reviews of the top-rated KitchenAid toasters handpicked by our team. If you are in a hurry to order, we recommend the KitchenAid Kmt4115cu 4-Slice Toaster (see Amazon) that has a sturdy stainless steel function with versatile functions to cater to a small family needs and even accommodate food for guests.

CapacityShade Control
Removable Crumb Tray
#1. KitchenAid Pro Line Series Sugar Pearl Silver 2-Slice Automatic Toaster2-Slice7YesSee Details
#2. KitchenAid KMT2115OB Toaster, Onyx Black2-Slice5YesSee Details
#3. KitchenAid KMT3115ER 2 Slice Long Slot High-Lift Lever Toaster2-Slice6YesSee Details
#4. KitchenAid KMT4203FP Pro Line Series Frosted Pearl White 4-Slice Automatic Toaster4-Slice7YesSee Details
#5. KitchenAid Kmt4115cu 4-Slice Toaster with Manual High-Lift Lever4-Slice5YesSee Details
#6. KitchenAid KMT4116ER 4 Slice Long Slot Toaster with High Lift Lever4-Slice7YesSee Details

#1. KitchenAid Pro Line Series Sugar Pearl Silver 2-Slice Automatic Toaster

This Pro-Line Series two-slice automatic toaster from the KitchenAid family comes enfitted with a wide range of features to enable easy and effortless toasting. It has a keep-warm function that enables the toaster to stay warm automatically for up to 3 minutes after the toasting is completed.

It comes with an auto lift and lower function to get the bread down into the self-centering rack and left it up after it has achieved the right shade. There are seven different shade settings to let you choose how light or dark you want your toast to be.

There are separate bagel and frozen functions to help you toast bagels or defrost with ease. We are impressed to know that the manufacturer stands behind the professional two-slice toaster and backs it up with a solid five-year limited warranty.

Product features

  • Measures 9.53 x 15.75 x 11.34 inches
  • Weighs 12.2 pounds
  • Automatic lift and lower
  • Sugar Pearl Silver
  • Keep’s toast warm automatically
  • 7 shade settings
  • Bagel and frozen functions

User/ Customer reviews

People are thoroughly impressed by this KitchenAid toasted that evenly toasts both the sides, making it a delight to make breakfasts every morning. Users also like the auto keep warm functionality that lets your toast stay eatable until you are ready to eat or serve. A few users have said that it’s too expensive for a toaster.


This is a well-designed and elegant looking KitchenAid Pro Line Series automatic toaster that perfectly goes with any kitchen décor. Besides its ease of use and functional design, this unit also comes backed by a 5 year manufacturer warranty.

Check Price Now

#2. KitchenAid KMT2115OB Toaster, Onyx Black

If looks matter to you as much as performance does then we suggest that you check out the KitchenAid KMT2115OB that shines in a gorgeous black exterior. With two wide slots, this toaster has the capability to toast your bread to just the shade you want, and even reheat a previously toasted bread in less than a minute.

The KMT2115OB comes with a high lift lever to make it easier to take out even small slices of bread when desired. There are separate bagel and cancel buttons that allow you to decrease the power on one side by 50 percent

Made from stainless steel, the exterior boasts a sturdy construction. 5 different settings let you choose how light or brown you want your toasts. With this one appliance, you toast bagels, English muffins, and even thick bread such as sourdough.

Product features

  • Measures 7.30 x 11.30 x 8.30 inches
  • Weighs 4 pounds
  • Made from Stainless Steel
  • 5 settings
  • Manual High-Lift Lever
  • Bagel and Cancel Buttons

User/ Customer reviews

Those who have bought this toaster were sold on the attractive looks that make it a pretty addition to the kitchen counter. Most customers have said that you must be careful when toasting bread as the unit runs a bit hot, so be careful with the settings. A few users have warned about an annoying beep that does not go well with everyone.


If you are looking for a nice toaster and prefer your slice of toast a bit darker then the KitchenAid KMT2115OB is a good option. It has a sturdy and stylish looking exterior that compliments the kitchen décor and delivers a good performance too. If you don’t mind that annoying beep then this can be a good investment for you.

Check Price Now

#3. KitchenAid KMT3115ER 2 Slice Long Slot High-Lift Lever Toaster

If red is your color and you want that perfect little red toaster for your kitchen then check out the KitchenAid KMT3115ER. This high-lift level toaster comes with two slices long slot that can accommodate a variety of bread, even the thick ones without having to adjust the size.

This little unit can easily toast frozen pastries or bread in less than a minute, and the high-lift level functionality helps in taking out even the smallest slice of bread. There is also a removable slide-out tray for easy cleaning and emptying any crumbs.

The well-designed construction also includes self-centering racks that ensure uniform heating for the thin and thick bread. It has a bagel button that allows you to toast the cut section of the bagel and letting the outside area warm gently. There are also defrost and little longer settings for ease.

Product features

  • Measures 16.10 x 5.40 x 7.90 inches
  • Weighs 4.1 pounds
  • Stainless Steel
  • High lift lever
  • Extra-wide 1 1/4” slots
  • Removable Crumb Tray

User/ Customer reviews

The sleek profile, art-deco appearance, and ease of use make the KitchenAid KMT3115ER a winner in the true sense of the word. Unlike the other models, this unit does not make any annoying buzzer sound. Whether you like to make a toast every morning or wish to use this toaster to warm bagels or defrost, this is a good choice.


This long slot toaster allows you to toast 2 to 4 slices of bread in a few minutes. Besides the stylish appearance of the unit, it is also extremely versatile to help you toast frozen foods too. Overall, we feel this is a terrific toaster for anyone to use.

Check Price Now

#4. KitchenAid KMT4203FP Pro Line Series Frosted Pearl White 4-Slice Automatic Toaster

If a simple yet beautiful toaster is on your mind then check out the no-frills KitchenAid KMT4203FP from the Pro-Line Series of KitchenAid. It sports a pearl white exterior and comes with a wide range of features to enable easy and effortless toasting.

There is an automatic Keep Warm function that lets you keep your toasts, bagels, and other items warm for up to 3 minutes. It comes with an automatic lift that helps to lower the bread into the rack and pushes it up when the desired shade is achieved.

With the seven shade settings, it’s easier than ever before to choose a light to dark toast. You may also use the bagel button and frozen functions to toast the bagels or defrost frozen food. The product is backed by a five-year limited manufacturer warranty.

Product features

  • Measures 16 x 15 x 10.1 inches
  • Weighs 18.2 pounds
  • Automatic Keep Warm function
  • Bagel and frozen functions
  • Five years limited warranty

User/ Customer reviews

People have said that this toaster works great and the crumbs tray makes it easy to clean and maintain after use. Several users have mentioned how this large-sized unit is perfect for big as well s small slices of bread. A few customers have warned that the toaster takes a lot of time to warm up and the bread becomes too dry.


This is a slightly bulky but good performing KitchenAid toaster (see Amazon) that performs like a dream and comes with various functions to help you use various types of bread to toast. At this price, this is one of the most versatile units money can buy.

Check Price Now

#5. KitchenAid Kmt4115cu 4-Slice Toaster with Manual High-Lift Lever

When you don’t want to compromise with your toast quality and also want the kitchen countertop to look good, we suggest the KitchenAid Kmt4115cu 4-Slice Toaster. It comes with a manual high-lift lever to toast the slices of bread or sides of bagels to your desired shade.

The unit has four extra-wide slots that are 1 1/2 inches wide, enough to accommodate different types of stuff such as, English muffins, bagels thick bread, and more. Made from stainless steel, the exterior has a sturdy appeal and stylish appearance.

There is also a removable tray to collect any crumbs and an under-base Cord Storage to make it easier to maintain the product. The high-lift manual lever further makes it easier to take out whatever you are toasting.

Product features

  • Measures 11.5 x 12.5 x 8.3 inches
  • Weighs 8 pounds
  • 4 Extra-Wide Slots
  • Bagel and Cancel Buttons
  • Made from stainless steel

User/ Customer reviews

Users have said that this KitchenAid Kmt4115cu stands up to the expectations from the brand that is known to produce aesthetically pleasing appliances. While people are impressed with the looks and performance of the product, a few have warned that the unit gets to get too hot.


This is a beautifully designed 4-slice toaster that perfectly caters to the needs of a large family with varied tastes. While it looks great on the kitchen counter, please remember to control the toasting process if you want something in lighter shades.

Check Price Now

#6. KitchenAid KMT4116ER 4 Slice Long Slot Toaster with High Lift Lever

Contemporary kitchens deserve something unique and interesting, such as the KitchenAid KMT4116ER made from metal for a seamless finish. Furthermore, if you have a large family, this toaster with a 4 slice long slot toaster and a high lift lever can cater to the needs of all.

We appreciate the long slot design with extra-wide slots that help in accommodating large and thick sizes of bread as well as thin ones. There is a removable crumb tray that collects the dirt and makes It easy to discard them after toasting is complete.

There are seven different settings to help you achieve the accurate shade for a bagel, reheat, defrost, and keep warm functions. It also includes an under base cord storage to keep the kitchen countertop clean and clutter-free.

Product features

  • Measures 7.70 x 16.50 x 8.00 inches
  • 4-slice long slot toaster
  • Extra-Wide Slots
  • Long slots design
  • 7 shade setting
  • High lift lever

User/ Customer reviews

People have said that the toaster has the capacity to make large sourdoughs to small slices of bread with equal ease without getting too hot. Users have said that the build quality is reasonably good and the control unit evenly heats to give toasts a perfectly uniform shade


This is a well-built toaster that gets up really fast and toasts bread correctly to brown the edges and in the middle without turning the bread dry. If you have a contemporary kitchen and wish to buy something that can blend with the décor then this is a good choice.

Check Price Now

Related Questions

How to clean a KitchenAid toaster

We suggest that you use a soft damp cloth to wipe the toaster, and clean the tray. Avoid using any abrasive cleaning item or harsh chemicals to clean the product.

Can I put a toaster in a dishwasher

Not at all. This is an electrical appliance that can be completely damaged if soaked in water, so always clean the unit manually. You may use water mixed with baking soda to get rid of stains and bad odor on it.

How long does the KitchenAid toaster last

Most of the models will last for 6-8 years of use. If you are careful about maintaining the unit well and clean it regularly after use, it can last even more.

See Also:
6 Kitchenaid Refrigerators Reviews
5 Best KitchenAid Pasta Attachments
6 Best Meat Grinder Attachments For KitchenAid

Scroll to Top